Foundations 3: What Is ∂ᵢ? — Basis Vectors of the Tangent Space
∂ᵢ is not just a partial derivative but the i-th basis vector of the tangent space at a point, so a tangent vector is v = vⁱ∂ᵢ, and its basis and components transform in opposite ways.
∂ᵢ is not just a partial derivative but the i-th basis vector of the tangent space at a point, so a tangent vector is v = vⁱ∂ᵢ, and its basis and components transform in opposite ways.
∂ᵢ is not just a partial derivative but the i-th basis vector of the tangent space at a point, so a tangent vector is v = vⁱ∂ᵢ, and its basis and components transform in opposite ways.
Upper and lower indices are not decoration. Upstairs means “transforms like vector components,” downstairs means “transforms like the basis,” and a sum over one up and one down index always gives a number that does not depend on coordinates.
The basis and the components change in opposite ways for a single reason: the tangent vector v = v^i ∂_i must be independent of the coordinate system. Just as taller steps mean fewer steps, the basis and the components must move in opposite directions for their product, the actual vector, to be preserved.